All Things Reconsidered | A dream deferred

By: Wes Kimbell

Issue date: 11/28/07 Section: Opinion
  • Page 1 of 1
Opinion Columnist: Wes Kimbell
Opinion Columnist: Wes Kimbell

Media Credit: Cindy Osborn
[Click to enlarge]
Immigration and undocumented immigrants are hotly debated issues in the United States today. While there are fights about immigration policy, it seems nobody wins. No true immigration reform has passed on the federal level for years. Because of the unsuccessful comprehensive immigration reform, activists have resorted to pushing piecemeal legislation, hoping it will squeeze through the House, Senate and the president's veto pen.

The Dream Act is one of these piece-meal acts that hopes to change a portion of immigration policy a little bit at a time. A fellow Aggie has told me her story and how the immigration debate is directly affecting her life. She hopes other Aggies will join her in supporting the Dream Act. This is her story.

When Ana was 10, she and her family came to the U.S. to reunite with her father. When she started school, she became determined to learn the English language and adapt to her new culture. In middle school, she was involved with extracurricular activities and excelled in school.

Once in high school, she continued her involvement and was one of the top students in her class. She focused her time on helping her community in activities, such as being a mentor to elementary children through Big Brothers Big Sisters. She was also a member of the National Honors Society and the captain of the varsity soccer. She ended her high school experience by graduating as the salutatorian of her class with a perfect GPA.

Now, a student at Texas A&M, she continues to be involved by completing more than 90 hours of community service a semester among other activities.

Ana is proud to be close to graduating and because she has the opportunity to apply to graduate school to work on her doctorate in public administration.

However, Ana is in a bind.

She finds her college experience restricted. She wishes to study abroad but cannot do so. She is looking for an internship but she cannot find one. She wishes to travel out of state to attend conferences for her major, but she cannot. She wishes that she could drive, but she does not have a license and is not allowed to have one. Ana is a highly qualified, active community member but she cannot obtain work after graduation. Ana is an undocumented immigrant.

But, fortunately for Ana, Texas House Bill 1403 at least allows her to receive in-state tuition and apply for scholarships. Other states do not. But, Ana and thousands of others students will basically be forced to leave their homes when they finish their studies because they are not allowed to work in the U.S. without residency, even though they have spent most of their lives here.

These are highly qualified graduates that would increase the ingenuity in our country. The proponents of the act make the argument that these students are potentially to face the drain in our social service budgets, making it an asset in terms of payments of taxes and the attraction to a state of high wage employers seeking well-educated workers. These are hard working, valuable members of our community.

This is where the Dream Act comes in. The Dream Act is proposed federal legislation that hopes to change this. It's relatively simple. After six years, if the student has obtained a bachelor's degree or higher or served two years in the Armed Forces and maintained good moral character, they would qualify for permanent residency. This would allow the opportunity for employment.

But Ana says we don't need to fear amnesty. The act creates zero incentives for an increase in undocumented workers crossing the border. There is a five year residency requirement prior to the enactment and you must show proof of this requirement for fulfillment. The Act allows permanent residency only to those that qualify.

Students at Texas A&M, like Ana, are working hard to promote the Act. B.E.S.O., Destino, Lambda Theta Phi, Chi Upsilon Sigma, Phi Iota Alpha and MAES are A&M organizations fighting for passage of the Dream Act.

- Wes Kimbell is a senior international studies major.
Page 1 of 1

Article Tools


Give us your take on the story.
Be sure to include your name, major, and class year. Submissions without this information are subject to deletion.

By submitting a comment, you agree to thebatt.com's Terms of Use.

You may also send a Mail Call to The Battalion at mailcall@thebattalion.net


Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 14

Meagain

posted 11/28/07 @ 2:01 AM CST

Why do you insist on lumping in immigrants and 'undocumented immigrants' into one lump category? Most of the outrage against the amnesty acts of which you write are for illegal immigrants. (Continued…)

Cliff

posted 11/28/07 @ 8:52 AM CST

Ana is a criminal, everyday that she is illegal in the USA should count as a seperate charge. I am sure she can be productive in prison.

(1 reply)   Details   Reply to this comment

DJK

posted 11/28/07 @ 10:30 AM CST

This is a very complicated issue---you need to get some facts straight:

1) Despite being good people, Ana and her family are criminal illegal aliens. (Continued…)

Lee

posted 11/28/07 @ 12:16 PM CST

Shame on Texas A&M University & the state of Texas for supporting illegal activities such as this through the Texas House Bill 1403. Anna and other illegals should not receive in-state tuition to our great university. (Continued…)

Silence Doogood

posted 11/28/07 @ 12:58 PM CST

Look, I'm not going to rehash what Meagain and Lee had to say. I agree with them.

Dems are missing the point. 1. It is illegal. 2. These rights that we have are granted by constitution of the UNITED STATES for CITIZENS of the UNITED STATES. (Continued…)

Tracey Cleary '97

posted 11/28/07 @ 7:42 PM CST

My husband is a LEGAL immigrant. We did the interviews, filled out the papers and jumped through all the hoops. I honestly do not understand why there is even a discussion on making ILLEGAL immigrants legal across the board or giving them rights that we as citizens or legal immigrants have. (Continued…)

Irene

posted 11/28/07 @ 10:35 PM CST

As a legal immigrant who has been following the laws of the country that I wanted to live in - I resent all this pandering to law-breakers. There ARE legal ways of going about things. (Continued…)

anonymous1313

posted 11/29/07 @ 12:28 PM CST

ok so my question to you guys all here saying she shouldnt be getting all these rights is...then what should she do... quit school and go on welfare.. (Continued…)

(1 reply)   Details   Reply to this comment

Justin Gross

posted 11/30/07 @ 11:10 AM CST

"Illegal is Illegal"; this is the kind of narrow, black and white, stubborn thinking that is killing any meaningful resolution to the debate. Most of you that are not for the DREAM Act have never met (so you think) anyone that is in this situation. (Continued…)

ann

posted 12/01/07 @ 11:40 AM CST

Ana preserved despite the odds and she is not a criminal, she herself has not committed any crimes. She is a future productive member of society. In this country we don't punish people for their parents actions unless it involves immigration violations. (Continued…)

(1 reply)   Details   Reply to this comment

Post a Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Advertisement

 

Just In (AP Lead Stories)

Advertisement

  • News
  • Sports
  • Aggielife
  • Opinion
  • AP News
  • Advertising
  • Message Boards
  • Blogs
  • Online Extras
  • Games
  • Back Issues